Third place. That's the highest the modern-day Dodge Challenger has placed in both comparison tests we've invited it to and, coincidentally, third place was also last place. If we gave the win to the Camaro in one test and the Mustang in the other, why would we order up Mopar's big bruiser for a long-term test?

Though the Challenger was too big and heavy to keep up with the nimble Camaro and Mustang in our objective tests, it won us back in subjective reviews with stunningly good looks, a comfortable ride, and more charisma than President Obama...Continued